An analysis of freuds critique of religion essay

Eventually, Freud abandoned the idea of the system unconscious, replacing it with the concept of the Ego, super-ego, and id discussed below.

Sigmund Freud's views on religion

For, by its very nature, psychological interpretation alone cannot penetrate to the absolutely final or first reality: Jealousy produced the crime, which was committed collectively, because only as group could the sons muster the strength for it.

About this resource This coursework was submitted to us by a student in order to help you with your studies. Why does the principle of intellectuality, which is operative in the constitutive function of fatherhood as well as in the move towards monotheistic religions, seem to be an autonomous function that requires not only recognition, but adoration.

His family had limited finances and lived in a crowded apartment, but his parents made every effort to foster his intellect often favoring Sigmund over his siblingswhich was apparent from an early age. It would not surprise us if we were to find a special psychical agency which performs this task of seeing that narcissistic satisfaction from the ego ideal is ensured and which, with this end in view, constantly watches the actual ego and measures it by that ideal….

The one you promised to bless the whole world through. Freud ultimately, in light of Eckstein's history of adolescent self-cutting and irregular nasal and menstrual bleeding, concluded that Fliess was "completely without blame", as Eckstein's post-operative hemorrhages were hysterical "wish-bleedings" linked to "an old wish to be loved in her illness" and triggered as a means of "rearousing [Freud's] affection".

He admits that he did not consider the content and the sources of religious experience, but merely the functioning of the symptom in the psychic economy and as a cultural system.

Freud’s Critique on Illusion and Delusion Essay

These electrons could be knocked off and we could transmute metals, or any other elemental matter. Jung did not agree with the distinction between content and meaning.

Some may ask why talk about Freud now when so many other issues crowd our tangled world. Therefore it creates a false impression of an enhanced conceptual and scientific precision even in what is dramatically obvious.

Indeed, it exists in every one of us in normal life. In the end, Freud could no longer tolerate the pain associated with his cancer. In this way the father becomes idealized and projected into the image of God.


But according to Freud, Dostoyevsky did not suffer from epilepsy but from hysteria. He discovers them underneath what we would call normal behavior and thinking, and as being far more pervasive than commonly thought. In this perspective, the secularization movement is simply the sign that societies mature; they outgrow and overcome the need for religions.

According to Freud, belief in God is merely a projection of powerful wishes and inner needs. The love towards the father turned into hatred because in the eyes of the sons he had all the women.

He argues that we all share an unconscious but strong wish for the protection of our parents, especially that of our fathers.

That they were seen in daylight really meant night, a fact that some internal repression caused the Wolf Man not to admit. This branch of Freudian critique owes a great deal to the work of Herbert Marcuse. We can only regret that certain experiences in life and observations in the world make it impossible for us to accept the premises of the existence of such a Supreme Being.

Or is our impression of the imperfection of the world simply an illusion. Questions concerning the traumas suffered by his patients seemed to reveal [to Freud] that Viennese girls were extraordinarily often seduced in very early childhood by older male relatives; doubt about the actual occurrence of these seductions was soon replaced by certainty that it was descriptions about childhood fantasy that were being offered.

The dead father returns, but now he has become the Other: This murder, according to Freud, is the missing link that explains the functioning of prohibition in the economy of the drives.

Most of these infantile neuroses are overcome spontaneously in the cause of growing up, and this is especially true of the obsessional neuroses of childhood. In the female version the Electra complex girls between the ages of yrs envy their father for possessing a penis that they have been denied.

The structure becomes manifest in the paranoid psychotic; but it is essentially the same for the person who believes in God. He analyzes it as if it were a physical force and distinguishes the source somatic originthe aim the experience of satisfactionthe impetus the force or degree of tensionand the object of the drive what allows drive satisfaction.

Independently of any truth contained therein, psychological language and terminology is amusing, not to say ridiculous. Among them it asserts that there are no sources of knowledge of the universe other than the intellectual working over of carefully scrutinized observations, and none that is derived from revelation, intuition or divination.

On the individual level, an infantile trauma in early childhood leads to some sort of compromise formation.

The Fraud of Freud

You are afraid, probably, that they will not stand up to the hard test. He also discovered what he called a correspondence between the nose and the genitals. As we know, developments in one scientific or technological field influence other disciplines, even when those developments are not applicable, or possibly applicable but with many limitations.

The same year he married Martha Bernaysthe granddaughter of Isaac Bernaysa chief rabbi in Hamburg. Critically Evaluate Freud's Theory Sigmund Freud () he was Jewish and educated in Vienna, where he trained in medicine.

Sigmund Freud – Essay Sample Abstract Sigmund Freud developed the theory of personality development, a philosophy of human nature and a method of psychotherapy which focuses on ones unconscious and those elements that motivate behavior.

Published: Mon, 5 Dec Introduction The purpose of this essay is to examine and evaluate Freud’s claim that his theories are supported by his case histories.

Free Coursework

JSTOR is part of ITHAKA, a not-for-profit organization helping the academic community use digital technologies to preserve the scholarly record and to advance research and teaching in sustainable ways.

Sigmund Freud Essay - Sigmund Freud Sigmund Freud was the first major social scientist to propose a unified theory to understand and explain human behavior. No theory that has followed has been more complete, more complex, or more controversial. by Jimmie Moglia for the Saker blog.

I first read Freud’s writings when, probably unconsciously, I believed that if everybody says the same thing, it must be true. Freud’s extraordinary theories and mystifying lingo had many admirers and promoters.

An analysis of freuds critique of religion essay
Rated 5/5 based on 86 review
Freud's View of Religion | Philosophical Explorations